Last night's dramatic Home Run Derby has surely peaked this All-Star Week's fame and has given bettors a whole lot to think about for tonight's MLB All-Star Game. Although this game is tough to bet on, there are still some props we can dive into to make a solid profit. Here are today's picks brought to you by BetOnline.ag. Click here to join. All new players get a 50% welcome bonus and up to $250 in free bets.
First Pick: Under 7 Runs
Rundown: The All-Star Game typically skews low — the under has cashed in 5 of the last 7 years. With two dominant starting pitchers on tap and lights-out bullpens waiting their turns, scoring will likely be minimized. Managers will emphasize matchups and situation-based substitution, further limiting offensive firepower. A tight, low-scoring showdown is the most likely scenario.
Second Pick: American League Moneyline
Rundown: The AL has dominated recent All-Star Games, winning 10 of the last 11 contests. With elite starter Tarik Skubal set to take the mound alongside strong AL relievers, the trend seems likely to continue. Their lineup depth — featuring stars like Aaron Judge batting third — gives the AL a clear advantage in a short exhibition format. Betting the AL outright is a smart play based on momentum and talent.
Third Pick: Aaron Judge to Record a Hit
Rundown: Judge enters the All-Star Game in elite form, batting well over .300 in July and showing his usual gap-to-gap power. He’s expected to bat third for the American League, meaning he should get at least two plate appearances. Even against elite arms, Judge’s approach and discipline give him a strong chance to put one in play. With the way he’sswinging right now, backing him to notch a hit feels like a safe and smart prop.